Thursday, 17 September 2015

The Relative Importance of Challenges

I've spent so long blogging about the Core Set card reviews that I've almost forgotten that it's not really what I want to be blogging about.  What drives people to play games is often very different, some are competitive, some are casual, some are social, some just enjoy escapism into the game world.... but for me the main reason I play games is to try and 'solve' them.  I approach games from the sense of trying to learn the language of the game design and understand underlying mechanics - what lies behind the rules of the game.

This is very true in video games as well as in board games, and it's just as true that often the language of game design common across multiple games (but can also be very unique to a particular game).  So in video games you'll often find hidden rewards in hard to reach places - a health potion, a new weapon, a shiny golden star to collect.  These are all rewards for exploring the game more fully and they've become so common across multiple games that players expect them to be there and will explore, and because players have learned to explore designers have learned to put something there to reward them for doing so.
Nowadays we find a locked door in a video game and we understand that the language of the game was that the door is there for a reason.  If there's a door there must be a key, and even if we don't need to open the door to progress onto the next level the door has to be there for some reason.  So we hunt for the key, we look in every corner and  tap every wall looking for a hidden cupboard... because we know there has to be a key.  And then we find the key, and we open the door, and there's an extra life inside.  We explored and were rewarded, hurrah!
This all happens because somebody designed the game world with us in mind.
Try that in real life.  A locked door stays locked because it's not for us.  It's for the maintenance man, whose path through the 'level' of our office block has nothing to do with our path as a 'player' (or worker).  If you hunt in every desk drawer in the office and pull the water cooler apart you still won't find the key for that door, because it's not been designed that we should have access.  And if we did somehow get it open, say we found a crowbar or drilled the lock (showing lateral problem-solving thinking, as some games require) would we find an extra life behind that door?  No.  We'd probably find controls for the air conditioning and an old mop and bucket.
Skyrim is a great example of a game that has a specific language you can learn.  Skyrim is a game of adventuring into dungeon after dungeon, going deeper and deeper into the earth through labyrinthine mazes of enemies and traps.  At the end of each dungeon will be a boss - we learn this very quickly, and indeed we learned it from hundreds of games before Skyrim - and if we defeat that boss there will be a reward.  And then after we claim our reward do we have to run back up through that whole dungeon we just cleared?  No!  Because in Skyrim every secret undead lair, every vampire's tomb, every dwarven ruin or spider's lair has a handy shortcut back to the surface right behind the boss!  You soon learn that this is part of the design language, and so when you enter an unfamiliar cavern and defeat an unfamiliar boss you know to look for the shortcut out, because you know there will be one.
But it wasn't in the manual that the shortcut would be there.  It's not a mechanic of the game or of any of the items you pick up or classes you play or quests you choose.  It's deeper than than all that.
And I love things like this.  I love decoding how games were designed and how they work.  The attraction of any game, for me, is seeing beyond the rules and the playing pieces to the mechanism underneath and, often, discovering what the game is actually about.

Where was I?  Oh yes, this is a blog about the A Game of Thrones LCG. 
I wanted to talk about Challenges, and the relative value of the three different types of challenges you can make.  It's a debate I've seen a few times: what's more important, Military, Intrigue or Power?  On the CardgameDB forums I saw somebody post "we all agree it's Intrigue > Power > Military" and literally the first reply was somebody saying "no, it's the reverse, Military > Power > Intrigue".
So, which is the right way around?
Well, first of all the most obvious answer is 'it depends'.  It depends on the board state - a military challenge when your opponent has Robert Baratheon as their only character is much better than a military challenge when they've got three cheap characters to lose as well, and a Power challenge to gain your 15th Power and win the game is a lot better than a Power challenge to claim your first Power.  It also depends on the cards in hand or play, so Plaza of Punishment makes Power challenges more important, Lannisport makes Intrigue challenges better, and so forth.
But going deeper than that, underlying the specific board states or cards we've drawn in games, which is more important?  All other things being equal, should I be throwing a Military challenge or an Intrigue challenge?
Again, I think it depends, but this time I think it depends in a way that we can begin to use to help us form decision making, around both the plays we make and the decks that we build.  This time it depends based on what point of the game we're in...

ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL Military challenges are best in the first few turns of the game, that's when being a dominant military force is most likely to turn into a win.  This is because typically your opponent's ability to play new characters is going to outstrip your ability to kill characters, especially if you're only using Military claims to do so.  In the early game you've the greatest chance of being able to kill all of your opponent's characters with a surge of claims and kills.  Ultimately you can then lock them off the board by killing any character they try to play after that.  As the game progesses your opponent plays more and more characters, or duplicates and Bodyguards, so he has more and more 'padding' around his key cards and your Military claims lose value.
I've seen the term 'pillow fort' used a few times and that refers to times when you have so many cheap characters out that however hard your opponent hits you with Military claim it doesn't really hurt.  It's very difficult to have that on turn 1, but will naturally develop over time if you allow it to.
So is Military useless if you can't start it straight away?  No, but you usually need to work much harder to make it relevant again.  This is why I still use Wildfire Assault in my aggressive Military decks even though my main plan should see me with lots of characters and my opponents having none.  I need Wildfire Assault because if Plan A doesn't work (I get a poor setup, my opponent opens with A Game of Thrones as his plot, etc) then I need to be able to break apart his pillow fort with Wildfire Assault on turn 3 or 4 and then try and capitalise from there to make my Military claims count.


ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL Power challenges become more important as the game nears a conclusion and one player gets close to winning.  In the early game it's more important to be trying to gain tactical advantages on the board with Military or taking cards away from your opponent with Intrigue - you could fight hard to gain power today at the price of sacrificing power in the next three turns if your characters are all dead or your hand is discarded.
As players get towards 10 power, though, it becomes a red alert for power challenges and the importance of the board position switches - now you could fight for Military control only to find the game ends before you can really make that advantage work for you if your opponent is happy to sit back and use Dominance and a couple of Power challenges to win the game.

I left Intrigue for last because it's perhaps the most complex to understand, but ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL Intrigue challenges are best during a window of a few turns in the middle of the game. 
So why is this?
Well, in the first few turns of the game the danger of being locked out by losing all your characters to Military challenges is likely to be your main focus of attention.  Also in the early game your opponent has a relatively big hand of cards, and although taking any card out of his hand is good there's a good chance that taking him down to 5 cards instead of 6 won't really affect too badly what he wants to do on his next turn.  Intrigue challenges in the early game are good because they lead into making stronger Intrigue challenges in the midgame a turn earlier than you would otherwise get to that point, but in terms of immediate impact they're usually less important than Military.
Towards the end of the game your opponent has likely played out most of the cards in his hand and unless he's got a really strong draw engine like The Red Keep or The Mander he's probably down to topdecking two cards each turn and putting them into play, leaving you with little in the way of a target for Intrigue challenges.
In the midgame, though, when you're not in danger of losing your best cards to Military challenges and your opponent has only a moderately sized hand, is when Intrigue really shines.  This is where you can rip the last couple of cards from your opponent and force him into topdecking mode a couple of turns early, while you still have extra ammunition in hand.  At that point, ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL, you should be able to win through simply having more cards than your opponent, which should turn into more successful Military challenges, more successful Power challenges, winning more Dominance phases... and ultimately victory.

All together now: it depends!
The real answer isn't that one is more important than the others, the real answer is that when you're building your deck with a strategy of Military/Intrigue/Power in mind you need to be aware of which part of the game you're trying to dominate.  A slow Military deck is probably going to struggle to make their challenges meaningful, likewise a quick Power deck will race to 7 or 8 power and then find that all of their characters are dead and they've no cards in hand, and so find themselves eventually overtaken on the way to 15 power.  Intrigue decks, on the other hand, have to play a careful balancing act and be ready to take control of the game halfway through and make the advantage count of forcing your opponent into topdecking mode.
And none of this is in the rulebook.  There's no card that makes Military challenges better on the first turn than any other turn, no card that means your Intrigue challenges discard more cards on turn three than they do on turn one.  The only thing similar is the broad strength boosts that Doran Martell gives out based on your plot discard deck, but those aren't tied to a specific type of challenge.
The question of which challenge is most important is defined by the underlying game mechanics.  The relative strength of Military and Intrigue challenges comes about because of the balance between the rate at which players can draw and play cards, while the late game inevitability of Power challenges comes about because the amount of Power in the game ticks up throughout the game through Dominance, unopposed challenges and Renown.  If you played with the core mechanics of the game like this the balance between the challenge types would be disrupted - make characters more expensive and Military challenges get better, for instance, give players more cards and gold each turn and they'd get worse.
ALL THINGS BEING EQUAL the balance of the game is such that the various challenges all have their time to really shine and define who wins games.  Understanding why and when each challenge is going to be strongest is a good first step in learning to think about the game on a deeper level than what is written on the cards or in the rulebook.
And that's why I play games.


  1. ...And that's why I read your blogs!

    I feel like I've gained more insight here than I did in my first six month of Netrunner. And I'm only picking up my first core today!

    Thanks David!


  2. Healthisgod is the only complete health and wellness website that you may describe as it yours. We created a site that introduces the collection of health and lifestyle information supported by reliable content providers and genuine user reviews. This is a sincere effort on our part to bring forth a user experience which is engaging, moving, and interactive. Visit for more- Health is God

  3. I’ve been writing essays for how many years and today I’m more on academic essay writing and I’m happy to be like my dad, a professional writer.Read more Kim kardashian sex tape and Mia Khalifa Sex video and Sunny Leone Sexy Movie

  4. Nutra Trials defines personal characteristics of different health products including skincare, weight loss, muscle and male enhancement. The study presented here is briefly described for reader convenience and to deliver them assurance with health standards. The best possible answers are given here regarding the selection of an ideal supplement or cream or serum that possibly remains to be safe for health and do not cause any side effects.

  5. It is a great job, I like your posts and wish you all the best. and I hope you continue this job well.
    NutraT line

  6. Hello, I am thomus jons thank you for this informative post. That is a great job. Wish you more success.Thank you so much and for you all the best. Takes Down

  7. Times For Health is Online Health & Wellness Program! Your post is so informative and i got everything from it. Thanks again!

  8. TecSmash is your ultimate source of Technology news and Make Money Online product reviews. We research and review all Tech, MMO, Biz Opp and IM products.

  9. Healrun is a health news blog we provide the latest news about health, Drugs and latest Diseases and conditions. We update our users with health tips and health products reviews. If you want to know any information about health or health product (Side Effects & Benefits) Feel Free To ask HealRun Support Team.

  10. Here is our FB SociCake Review, in which I have revealed the good, bad and ugly about Mario Browns FB SociCake Facebook Marketing Tool. socicake


  11. Pilpedia is supplying 100 percent original and accurate information at each moment of time around our site and merchandise, and the intent is to improve the usage of good and pure health supplement. For More Info please visit Pilpedia online store.

  12. Supplements For Fitness In general, all natural supplements are generally safer than over-the-counter medications and prescription medications. They have fewer side effects and are less likely to interact with other medications you are .

  13. We are here to give you a complete review on the Parallel Profit project by Steve Clayton and Aidan Booth. If you are someone from the field you would already be familiar with these two names, for those of who are new. Parallel Profits Review

  14. is dedicated to bring you the best in Internet Marketing, Blogging and the entire Make Money Online spectrum. We are your finest source of info.

  15. Our vision is that people find best quality health products they need; that the health products are safe and affodable for them. Supplements Angles (

  16. erstwhile been hour. And, although easily tempted by candy, I hold to existence somewhat of a material candy snob by believing that intense it from a pre-packaged containerful robbed it of all the delights of its intentional fluffy utility and st necessary. Certainly it would reappear one day from down a vanity or from under a nap of books during a cleanup fling, probably around Easterly, thereby making it a moot bushel at the end of my smell. I was some to grooming my freedom not to select, which is out of recommendation for me as I love a freebie, when I noticed something magically materialize on the base of the three-ringed centerpiece. Life-like, tiny hominian safekeeping, apiece alert atop a tubing, were set in a vase to deceive a lilliputian bouquet of beige daffodils. There was a diabolical loveliness around them, and I was straightaway entertained. Without cerebration or faltering I shook one unrestrained from its previous opus and chose the fingerbreadth puppet of a tiny hominian help to accompany me throughout the day. The tiny handbreadth and I did not share fellowship anytime movieshook

  17. The Probiotic supplement helps to balance good bacteria and in this regard, Probiotic t 50 review is creating buzz. How far is the supplement reliable and worth considering, you will come to know about it here.

  18. Don't Waste Time! 5 Facts Until You Reach Your Adtrics Academy -

  19. skintology md cream is very effective and cheap solution to get rid of annoying skin lesions on your body like moles, and skin tags by Skintology MD. It is a safe way to solve the skin problems that you have. This cream has been designed to cater to all skin types. Be it oily or normal, dry or sensitive, it works on all skin types. This works really fast and better than other expensive methods like surgery.Visit On

  20. This hormone is most basic for the support of his sexual wellbeing and with age it decreases, however more youthful men may likewise have testosterone inadequacy for different reasons.

  21. Call Now at 7634078909 to grab a Free SEO consultation from the certified SEO consultant at Elite SEO Agency.

    Boost your online website promotion & convert your coaching institute business into a steady recurring online income!


  22. Sapiens IAS offers flexible and results-oriented Best Anthropology Coaching Coaching for UPSC and IAS students through an online and offline training program by well known IAS trainer Mr. Pradip Sarkar.

    Call: 8700922126 || 011-2875 6962 || 9718354962
    Address: 17A/44, W.E.A. 3rd Floor, Near Karol Bagh Metro Station (Pillar No. 99), New Delhi- 110005.

    Read More at:

  23. TecSmash is your ultimate source of Technology news and Make Money Online product reviews. We research and review all Tech, MMO, Biz Opp and IM products.

  24. Just like you will find in most of the 28 Day Keto Challenge Review on the internet, this guide narrows down to the precise understanding of everything that goes into eliminating carbs from your diet.

  25. Depending on your needs, choosing male enhancement products can sometimes be overwhelming. If you're looking to improve your size and performance then you've got a couple of choices to make.

  26. aboutthemcat
    Keto mould is very effectual as it does not alteration our embody and helps us to retrograde coefficient rattling easily. This is the finest product play? Slimquick Keto totality on the symptom configuration. Keto descriptor is real famous for Weight-loss, as it does not wage any change to the imperfect embody and decreases your weight by removing the histrion fat from your body. Acetonemia is rattling calculative to obtain as it needs kosher work and halal fasting to express it frontward. Keto taxon runs on substance with high-fat intensity and low abstraction of calories. It is real serious for a someone on acetonemia to avow erstwhile obtained demand a straightlaced fast and suitable exercises for the c CLICK for more info>>>

  27. Ultra Fast Keto Boost For Weight Loss This formulation is created of natural ingredients, so that square measure the foremost crucial compounds. That ease to offer the organic compound within the body, thereby increasing the quantity of BHB. By the regular use of this supplement, the human body is performed within the acetonemia technique. It can help to rework undesirable carbohydrates into energy. With this supplement, you will have the ability to burn fat faster than ever before. Visit On

  28. Alka Tone Keto Reviews weight reduction supplement contains 100% normal and natural Keto Tone Reviews fixings and it's recommended by the specialists and specialists. Alka Tone Keto Reviews contains a good assortment of vitamins and minerals. It's the simplest mix of various powerful fixings. This item contains very good powerful fixings which enhance the final body and deals with the weight. Visit On

  29. When you feel that you are no longer able to control your appetite and all you want to
    do is keep eating then it’s time for you to start using Leptitox Diet Pills.
    <a href="">Leptitox Real

  30. There are a lot of fast solutions that one can buy nowadays. But most of the male enhancement
    pills readily available work just for one or two sessions and after that wane. One can sure get a
    hit from them yet they do not function in the long run. If you are trying to find structure from
    durability from the within then Massive Male Plus is one supplement that you could go for.
    <a href="">Leptitox Real Reviews</a>

  31. Most everyone is looking for a quick, simple answer to “how to start loosing weight”. And as much as a reasoning similar to, “having a healthier body”, should give us the motivation for change, often that’s just not the case. We want to, “look sexier”, “fit into old, cute clothes”, “have our significant other desire our body”, etc. Determining your core motivation is a critical aspect prior to initiating effective diet & exercise plans. The driving factor or reason for your desired BioHarmony Advanced Drops weight loss should be written out, and kept in a secret spot near a fit picture of you or someone who’s figure you hope to resemble upon reaching your weight loss goal.

    After you have defined your inspiration for becoming healthier & achieving weight loss, onto step 2. Taking before pictures & measurements can be very beneficial throughout weight loss & after reaching your goal as a preventive measure. Front, back, & side pictures taken against a white wall with as little clothing as possible is best (underwear, bra, etc).
    BioHarmony Advanced Drops Reviews

  32. Try to lose fat and improve your health through "trial and error." Fly solo with the attitude "throw it on the wall and see what sticks." You may reach your goal at some point with this approach, but not without countless frustrations and setbacks that leave you on the verge of giving up.
    Custom Keto Diet Plan Review

  33. This is a website where natural health & fitness products are scrutinized with our unbiased reviews for the benefit of the customers out there. Here, natural products for health care are put to the test to see if they really stand up to their expectations and do what they claim they can do.Many people stick to one brand because they know their effectiveness through experience. They are afraid to use other products because they do not know if it will actually work at all.
    Natural Health program & supplement Reviews

  34. You will find reviews of different types of supplements & health programs. Nowadays, we realize that getting best products review are very difficult, but we promise you is always giving the honest benefits & side effects with an easy-to-understand.

    Supplement Reviews

  35. Bioptimizers CogniBiotics contains every strain you need to powerfully support your second brain, feel awesome, and be at your best. And this has prevented you from maximizing your mood, happiness, mental performance... as well as every other part of your health.
    Bioptimizers Cognibiotics Reviews

  36. LeptoConnect is a supplement that is mainly concerned in burning unwanted fats so as to give you faster weight-loss results. The stored fats are its main target and its makers were applauded because of this good objective. The best way to fight weight-gain is to prevent the growth of unwanted substances that contributes great in gaining more pounds.
    LeptoConnect Reviews

  37. LeptoConnect is a supplement that is mainly concerned in burning unwanted fats so as to give you faster weight-loss results. The stored fats are its main target and its makers were applauded because of this good objective. The best way to fight weight-gain is to prevent the growth of unwanted substances that contributes great in gaining more pounds.
    LeptoConnect Reviews

  38. LeptoConnect is a supplement that is mainly concerLeptoConnect is a supplement that is mainly concerned in burning unwanted fats so as to give you faster weight-loss results. The stored fats are its main target and its makers were applauded because of this good objective. The best way to fight weight-gain is to prevent the growth of unwanted substances that contributes great in gaining more pounds.
    LeptoConnect Reviews

  39. This is a website where natural health supplements & programs are scrutinized with our unbiased reviews for the benefit of the consumers out there.
    Belespas Reviews

  40. Even the Resurge Pills Review that I have gone through has not pointed out any negative effect of these capsules,and all of them are happy customers like my mother and me. You could go through other Resurge supplement reviews too and tally before you purchase it.

  41. Read Nervogen Pro Supplement Ingredients Benefits & Side Effects. Does NervoGen Pro Capsules Really Work Or Scam?
    NervoGen Pro